One topic that has been very actively discussed recently both on
Parliament Hill and in Okanagan Coquihalla is the Canadian Senate. There are generally three main perspectives that I hear from local citizens and from other Members of Parliament in Ottawa that include reforming the Senate, abolishing the Senate altogether and leaving the Senate alone…. taking the status quo approach. In these discussions I have also discovered that there are, at times, some misunderstandings of the legal status of the Senate and the obligations of Government to comply with legislation that, in some cases, is well over one hundred years old. One area that I frequently hear disdain for pertains to the practice of appointing various Canadians to the Senate. The question I am frequently asked is “Why doesn’t the Prime Minister stop appointing Senators and just get rid of the Senate?” The challenge is that the Senate, sometimes referred as the“Upper Chamber” or the “Other Place” (as it must be referred to within the House of Commons) is part of our Constitution. When the founders of Canadian Confederation created the Senate, they did so by essentially dividing Canada into five different regions: The Maritimes, Ontario, Quebec, Western and “Additional”. Additional includes Newfoundland, Labrador, NWT, Yukon and Nunavut. By design the Senate is not based on a representation by population model as is the House of Commons but rather on the principle of “equal”regional representation where the first four regions each have 24 seats while the “Additional” regions have 9 of the 105 seats in the Senate. Consequently the constitutionally mandated Senate representation arrangement means that regions of Canada are legally entitled to the number of seats as defined within the Constitution Act of 1867. To date every Prime Minister elected in Canada’s history has by legal obligation, appointed Senators when vacancies arise, most often created by a Senator reaching the mandatory retirement age of 75. In addition the Prime Minister can, in exceptional circumstance, also temporarily appoint 4-8 additional Senators if there is a deadlock that must be broken. One of the challenges to the Senate “equal”representation model is that it conflicts with representation by population. As an example the current Senate model ensures there are actually 30 Senate seats east of Quebec – that is six more Senate seats than the 24 in all of Western Canada combined. Likewise for Ontario in spite of having a much larger population than Quebec has the same number of seats in the Senate. As a result, some regions in Canada from a population perspective are under-represented compared to others. As an example here in BC there are 6 senators compared to 10 in Nova Scotia. When it comes to the discussion of abolishment of the Senate, many in western Canada are strongly in favour while some regions of Canada are equally as strongly opposed. Recently our Government has posed a series of six questions to the Supreme Court of Canada to request a ruling on how the Senate can be legally reformed or abolished in accordance with our Constitution – one of the many questions is a ruling on the need to determine if there is a requirement to have a Canadian constitutional debate involving all of the Provinces and Territories. Although many have expressed a desire to see action taken on the Senate, few have expressed interest in opening up a Canadian constitutional debate that could potentially pit different regions of the country against each other a time when national unity is critically needed. This will be the first time in over three decades that our Supreme Court will look at the issue of Senate reform in a review process that will ideally provide more clarity on how action can be taken on the subject of Senate reform and/or abolishment. I welcome your views on this subject. Dan Albas is the Member of Parliament for Okanagan-Coquihalla and can be reached via email at Dan.albas@parl.gc.ca
28 Comments
Fred Monteith
5/21/2013 02:37:14 am
Reform or abolition of the Senate is badly needed. It has become a home for retired political cronies and the cost is too high. The salaries alone are over 14 million dollars and the travel expenses probably doubles this figure. Recent events have shown us how useless the Senate really is.
Reply
12/25/2013 06:20:05 pm
I found this post an educational one to glance. Thank you for broadening my knowledge on this aspect to groom up my skills here.
Reply
12/25/2013 06:20:41 pm
Interesting topic shown here, i am now working on it regularly here and would say keep the future posts like this continusoly.
Reply
12/25/2013 06:21:18 pm
this blog post is sensational one to get a depth of knowledge i admire the writers creative release here an awesome one here
Reply
12/25/2013 06:21:48 pm
make this content go of a public one to get more users brushed up with their logics and thinkings. thanks a lot here.
Reply
12/25/2013 06:22:21 pm
Great conclusion to end up in this article for releasing a depth of knowledge and making us a more broad thinkers now.
Reply
1/10/2014 05:34:11 pm
I would definitely rate this as excellent subject to review, a much needed one for future concerns'Excellent explanations shown here, would make me more notifiable in future need of this occurrence 1/10/2014 05:35:52 pm
Hats off for publishing this unique comments here, would be used always for best outcomes. 1/10/2014 05:36:21 pm
No content is comparable and admirable then this mentioned for the explanations, a must one to read for everyone.
Reply
1/10/2014 05:36:45 pm
Great information shared with the users here, if eel delighted with it.
Reply
1/28/2014 01:43:59 pm
Great information shared with the users here, its noteworthy one to get a great information for future business purpose.
Reply
1/28/2014 01:44:27 pm
i liked this article published here on this superb platform, it needs to be followed wisely as mentioned for absolute results always
Reply
1/28/2014 01:44:48 pm
My reasearch work has just came to a conclusion after reading this brilliant masterpiece and i am making a wise decision to share it
Reply
1/28/2014 01:45:15 pm
another glorious work shown here, most outstanding one to have a quick access to article and recieve the results within a short time period.
Reply
1/28/2014 01:45:43 pm
These are really a superb showcases here I am glad to have a review of it and feel to roll on its steps for my benefit always
Reply
2/20/2014 06:53:21 pm
This post is so informative especially the images posted here do make this blog more outstanding in comparison to others maybe this post needs to be briefed here
Reply
2/20/2014 06:53:47 pm
Really these contents needs to be shared on social networking sites as they are really the brief and great masterpieces here
Reply
2/20/2014 06:54:14 pm
Got some depth knowledge in advance after having a quick and brief glance on to it, thanks a lot for sharing here on this webpage.
Reply
2/20/2014 06:54:34 pm
I am in need of some more video clippings here so that some more explanations are available here to share with me. that would be an added advantage for me to get more groomed up always.
Reply
3/17/2014 01:51:08 pm
Hats off for publishing this unique comments here, would be used always for best outcomes more often, the results would be positive always
Reply
3/17/2014 01:51:32 pm
No content is comparable and admirable then this mentioned for the explanations, a must one to read for everyone and get assisted a lot
Reply
3/17/2014 01:54:00 pm
Great information shared with the users here, its noteworthy one to get a great information for future business purpose.
Reply
3/17/2014 01:54:27 pm
i liked this article published here on this superb platform, it needs to be followed wisely as mentioned for absolute results always
Reply
3/17/2014 01:55:00 pm
My reasearch work has just came to a conclusion after reading this brilliant masterpiece and i am making a wise decision to share it
Reply
12/8/2013 04:59:02 pm
It is an obvious premise, but used cars have their reasoning. Some cars and older models worse than others and, with the same years and miles, tourism of a brand can be almost new and a different signature
Reply
1/28/2014 01:43:29 pm
No content is comparable and admirable then this mentioned for the explanations, a must one to read for everyone and get assisted a lot
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Subscribe to the MP ReportSign up now to get Dan's weekly MP report emailed directly to you!
OR Sign up now to get a monthly MP Report mailed directly to your home. AuthorDan Albas is the Member of Parliament for the riding of Central Okanagan-Similkameen-Nicola. Archives
February 2023
Categories |
Central Okanagan – Similkameen – Nicola